Convergence and Divergence between the Arabic ʿUdhrî (Chaste) Love and Platonic Love: A Comparative Study

Ahmed Thnaybat, Hussein Zeidanin

Abstract


The study explores the Udhrî ghazal as a classical literary phenomenon in the Arabic poetry; and it seeks to correlate it with Plato’s theories of love in The Symposium. The issues the study raises are: history of the Udhrî love, factors leading to its emergence, impact of Islam on the Udhrî poets, and stages of the Udhrî narrative based on classical Arabic poetry and prose. The study controverts the claims associating the Udhrî ghazal with Islam due to the profound discrepancies between Islamic teachings and the practices and behaviors of the Udhrî poets. It as well reviews the theories of love Plato introduces in the Symposium for the purpose of estimating their manifestations in classical Arabic prose and impact on the Udhrî ghazal. The beginnings of Udhrî love go back to the pre-Islamic era during which poets, such as Antara Al-Absi, frequently combined the motif of chaste love with other related topics in their poems. Yet, the Udhrî ghazal flourishes in the Umayyad age during which poets tackled Udhrî love as an autonomous motif and subgenre. The study further questions the various possible factors, i.e. political, religious, environmental and social, modernists believe have led to the evolution of the Udhrî ghazal in the Islamic age and the Umayyad age. 

 


Keywords


Udhrî love, Platonic love, Islam ,Modernists, Ghazal

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abu Sweilim, A. (1987). Studies in the Jahili Literature, Al-Jeel Publishing, Beirut.

Al-Absi, A. (2010). Diwan, Mohammed S. Al-Mawlawi (ed.), Islamic Office, Damascus.

Al-Adhim, S. J. (2002), In Love and the Udhrî Love, Al-Mada Dar for Culture and Publishing, Damascus.

Al-Alawi, M. H. (2013). Echoes of Plato’s Symposium in the Classical Discourse of Arab Prose, Sadana Cultural Journal, Retrieved from http://www.saddana.net/?p=12227

Al-Andalusi, M. (1977). Collar of the Dove, H. K. Al-Seirafi (Ed.), Al-Istiqama Publishing House, Cairo.

Al-Asfahani, M. (1985). Al-Zahra, I. Al-Samira'i. (Ed.), Al-Manar Bookshop, Zarqa (Jordan).

Al-Asfahani, M. (2011). Al-Aghani, A. Mhana and S. Jabir. (Eds.), Dar Al-Fikr for Publishing and Distribution, Beirut, 1999.

Al-Batal, A. (1984). The Udhrî Ghazal and Reality Disorder, Fussul: Journal of Literary Criticism, 4(2).

Al-Mulawah, Q. (1999). Diwan, A. B. Al-Wali (Ed.), Scientific Books Dar, Beirut.

Al-Nahhas, A. (1986). Guide to the Famous Poems Known as Muw'alaqat, Scientific Books Dar, Beiruit, 2.

Al-Shahawi, S. (2016). Ambiguity of Concepts across Civilizations: Udhrî Love as a Model, Arrafid, UAE, Retrieved from: http://www.arrafid.ae/arrafid/p16_6-2011.html

D’Arcy, M. C. (2007). The Mind and Heart of Love: Lion and Unicorn, A Study in Eros and Agape, Kessinger Publishing.

Dhaif, S. (1977). History of the Arab Literature, Al-Ma'arif Dar, Cairo.

Dhaif, S. (1999). The Arab Conception of the Udhrî Love, Lebanon Egyptian Dar, Cairo.

Hilal, M. G. (19760). The Emotional Life between the Udhrî Love and Sufi Love, Al-Nahda Dar, Cairo.

Hills, J., Julian G., and David P. (2002). Understanding Social Exclusion, Oxford University Press.

Hilmi, M. (1985). Ibn Al-Faridh and the Divine Love, Al-Ma'arif Dar, Cairo.

Hussein, T. (1976). Al-A'arbi'aa Talk, Al-Ma'arif Dar, Cairo.

Ibn Mandhour, M. (2011). Lisaan Al-Arab, entry “Jund”, Dar Al-Ma’arif.

Ibn Mu'amar, J. (1982). Diwan, Beirut Dar for Publishing and Distribution, Beirut.

Ibn Qutaiba, A. (1985). Poetry and the Poets, M. Qmaiha (Ed.), Scientific Books Dar, Beirut.

Khlaif, Y. (1995). In the Umayyad Poetry: a Study of the Environment, Gharib Bookshop, Cairo.

Khlaif, Y. (1998). The Arab Conception of the Ideal Love, Qibaa' Dar for Publishing and Distribution, Cairo.

Shukri, F. (1959). Development of Ghazal between the Pre-Islamic and Islamic Ages, Damascus Mosque Publishing.

Tawfiq, B. (2015). Chivalric Literature between the East and West, Al-Raya Newspaper, Qatar, Retrieved from:

http://www.raya.com/news/pages/b93d6ba1-820e-4f05-8fb9-20781a5394bb

Wadghiri, H. (2013). Theories of Love Based on Plato’s Symposium, The Civilized Debate, Retrieved from: http://www.ahewar.org/debat/show.art.asp?aid=340508




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijclts.v.5n.3p.44

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.




Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

2013-2019 (CC-BY) Australian International Academic Centre PTY.LTD.

International Journal of Comparative Literature and Translation Studies

You may require to add the 'aiac.org.au' domain to your e-mail 'safe list’ If you do not receive e-mail in your 'inbox'. Otherwise, you may check your 'Spam mail' or 'junk mail' folders.