Comparison between primary closure and T-tube drainage after open choledocotomy

Alireza Barband, Farzad Kakaei, Morteza Ghojazadeh, Abdolhamid Chavoshi Khamneh, Morteza Chavoshi Khamneh, Sina Zarrintan


Background: Common Bile Duct (CBD) exploration for choledocolithiasis is usually closed after T-tube insertion. However, complications of T-tube insertion limit its use. In the present study, we wanted to compare outcomes between primary repair of choledocotomy and traditional T-tube insertion. Material and methods: Thirty patients with CBD stones disease admitted at Sina and Imam Reza hospitals of Tabriz, from April 2012 to February 2013, were included in this study.  The patients were randomly divided into two groups: T-tube drainage group and primary closure group. Intraoperative findings and postoperative complications were recorded and analyzed. Results: There was no mortality and retained stones in both groups. Two of 15 patients in the T-tube group and four of 15 patients in primary closure group suffered from minor bile leakage. There was no major bile leakage in the T-tube group but one patient in the primary closure group had major bile leakage, which was treated conservatively without surgical or endoscopic intervention. Wound infection was seen in two patients in the T-tube group and one patient in the primary closure group. In follow up assessment, there was no intra-abdominal collection in both groups. Overall postoperative complications include biliary complications, wound infection and intra-abdominal collections, were seen in four patients in the T-tube group and six patients in primary closure group; that was not statically significant difference. Conclusion: primary closure of CBD after open choledocotomy is feasible and is as safe as T-tube insertion. In effect, primary closure avoids T-tube insertion and disadvantages associated with the use of T-tube. Primary closure can be recommended for selected patients with CBD stone disease.


Key words: common bile duct stones; choledocotomy; T-tube drainage; primary closure

Full Text:



Oddsdottir M, Pham TH, Hunter JG. Gallbladder and the extrhepatic biliary system. In: Brunicardi FC. editor. schwart's Principles of Surgery, 9th ed. United States of America: Mc Graw-Hill;2010. P 1148.

Williams JAR, Treacy PJ, Sidey P, et al. Primary duct closure versus T-tube drainage following exploration of the common bile duct. ANZ J Surg 1994;64:823–6.

Perez G, Escalona A, Jarufe N et al. Prospective randomized study of T-tube versus biliary stent for common bile duct decompression after open choledocotomy. World J Surg 2005; 29:869–872.

Gharaibeh KIA, Heiss HA. Biliary leakage following T-tube removal. Int Surg 2000;85:57–63.

Placer G. Bile leakage after removal of T-tube from the common bile duct. Br J Surg 1990;77:1075.

Zhang LD, Bie P, Chen P et al. Primary duct closure versus T-tube drainage following laparoscopic choledochotomy. Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi 2004;42:520–523.

Marwah S, Singh I, Godara R et al. Evaluation of primary duct closure vs T-tube drainage following choledochotomy. Indian J Gastroenterol 2004; 23:227–228.

Ambreen M, Shaikh AR, Jamal A, Qureishi JN, Dalwani AG, Memon MM. Primary closure versus T-tube drainage after open choledochotomy. Asian J Surg 2009;32:21-5.

Qian D. Zhu & Chong L. Tao & Meng T. Zhou & Zheng P. Yu & Hong Q. Shi & Qi Y. Zhang. Primary closure versus T-tube drainage after common bile duct exploration for choledocholithiasis. Langenbecks Arch Surg 2011; 396:53–62.

Verbesey JE, Birkett DH. Common Bile Duct Exploration for Choledocholithiasis. Surg Clin N Am 2008; 88:1315–1328.

De Roover D, Vanderveken M, Gerard Y. Choledochotomy: primary closure versus T-tube. A prospective trial. Acta Chir Belg 1989;89:320–324.

Martin IJ, Bailey IS, Rhodes M, et al. Towards T-tube-free laparoscopic bile duct exploration: A methodological evolution during 300 consecutive procedures. Ann Surg 1998;228:29.

Ahmed I, Pradhan C, Beckingham IJ, Brooks AJ, Rowlands BJ, Lobo DN. Is a T-tube necessary after common bile duct exploration? World J Surg 2008;32:1485-8.

Zhang LD, Bie P, Chen P et al. Primary duct closure versus T-tube drainage following laparoscopic choledochotomy. Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi 2004;42:520–523.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

2013-2018 (CC-BY) Australian International Academic Centre PTY.LTD.

Advances in Bioscience and Clinical Medicine